Over at the Senate Finance Committee, Republicans who have expended a lot of energy claiming that the federal government can't do anything right won a vote preserving $50 million a year for "abstinence-only" education programs.
President Obama’s first budget eliminated federal funding for such programs, instead putting money into “evidence-based” teen pregnancy prevention programs. But now, writes The New Republic's Suzy Khimm, "the Finance Committee vote could mean that Bush’s legacy will continue well past Obama’s first term, funding the so-called Title V block grants to states through 2014."
Sen. Orrin Hatch (R-Utah), the sponsor of the amendment that won by a 12-11 vote, appeared to recognize the dichotomy inherent in his efforts.
"“My first choice would be to not have the federal government involved in any way in these types of education programs,” Hatch said in a press statement. “However, if the federal government is going to spend money on educating people about sexual decisions, the absence of an abstinence only education program has negative health consequences for our nation’s most vulnerable citizens.”
Khimm put it this way: "In other words, if the federal government is going to go there, we might as well pile on."
A 2007 survey of more than 2,000 teenagers carried out by a research company on behalf of Congress found that the half of the sample given abstinence-only education displayed exactly the same predilection for sex as those who had received conventional sex education in which contraception was discussed. Twenty-three states currently have rejected abstinence-only funds, even in the midst of a deep recession that has left states starving for funding.
Immediately after the Hatch amendment vote, the committee also voted 14-9 to approve an amendment sponsored by Finance Committee Chairman Max Baucus (D-Mont.) that supported a more comprehensive approach to sex education passed. The amendment will provide funding to a wide range of teen wellness programs, including those dealing with contraception and HIV/AIDS. Those funds will support abstinence education programs that are deemed “medically accurate and complete.”
Wednesday, 30 September 2009
Diabetes: Where a Strong Case for Prevention is Ignored
If America is going to change health care, it's going to have to change diabetes. That's the conclusion of Dana Haza, senior director of the National Changing Diabetes® Program, in a column that appears in The Health Care Blog. She uses some compelling facts to back up her assertion.
"While the rates of undiagnosed diabetes and pre-diabetes are alarming, studies show that type 2 diabetes can be significantly prevented, or at least delayed, by losing weight through diet and regular exercise," Haza writes. "But, even with evidence supporting prevention, our nation isn’t allocating adequate resources. In 2005, a study by the National Changing Diabetes® Program found that the federal government spent nearly $80 billion more on those with diabetes than those without the disease, and only $4 billion of that was spent on prevention and health promotion."
"While the rates of undiagnosed diabetes and pre-diabetes are alarming, studies show that type 2 diabetes can be significantly prevented, or at least delayed, by losing weight through diet and regular exercise," Haza writes. "But, even with evidence supporting prevention, our nation isn’t allocating adequate resources. In 2005, a study by the National Changing Diabetes® Program found that the federal government spent nearly $80 billion more on those with diabetes than those without the disease, and only $4 billion of that was spent on prevention and health promotion."
Gould: More Science Needed on Incentives Based on Employees' Health Profiles
Partnership for Prevention President Robert J. Gould told National Journal that more science is needed to properly evaluate workplace wellness incentives that base employees' insurance rates on their individual health status.
Gould's comments were included in an article by Julie Kosterlitz on proposed legislation that lets employers offer workers discounts of as much as 50 percent for meeting specific health goals, such as smoking cessation, obesity, blood pressure and cholesterol. That would change a 1996 law that forbids discrimination by group health plans against workers based on their health status.
"Some leaders in the field of wellness and prevention have chosen not to endorse proposed legislation to change the 1996 law," Kosterlitz writes. 'We need more information before we can jump in and support this,'" said Rob Gould, president of Partnership for Prevention, an organization of businesses, nonprofits and governemnt agencies that advocate wellness. 'There are some case examples presented by companies, but it's not the kind of systematic evaluation' the group needs to satisfy its concerns.'"
Gould's comments were included in an article by Julie Kosterlitz on proposed legislation that lets employers offer workers discounts of as much as 50 percent for meeting specific health goals, such as smoking cessation, obesity, blood pressure and cholesterol. That would change a 1996 law that forbids discrimination by group health plans against workers based on their health status.
"Some leaders in the field of wellness and prevention have chosen not to endorse proposed legislation to change the 1996 law," Kosterlitz writes. 'We need more information before we can jump in and support this,'" said Rob Gould, president of Partnership for Prevention, an organization of businesses, nonprofits and governemnt agencies that advocate wellness. 'There are some case examples presented by companies, but it's not the kind of systematic evaluation' the group needs to satisfy its concerns.'"
Health Reform Bill Could Hit Senate Floor by Columbus Day, Reid Says
Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid says the full Senate could begin debating a sweeping health- reform bill on the week of Oct. 12. That would require that Senators forego their traditional week-long Columbus Day recess. Reid's comments come as the Senate Finance Committee continues to work on its version of the health reform bill.
Monday, 28 September 2009
Debate Brewing over Soda Tax
Soda taxes have been in the news a lot lately. On one side are public health experts who say that soda taxes could address our nation’s obesity problem. They cite the success tobacco taxes have had in reducing smoking rates and the relationship between soda consumption and body weight. An article in this month’s issue of the New England Journal of Medicine touts the health and economic benefits of taxing sugary drinks. The Institute of Medicine also recently released recommendations for local governments to combat childhood obesity that include implementing taxes to discourage consumption of foods with minimal nutritional value, which certainly include sugar-sweetened beverages.
Such taxes are also being discussed by policymakers. San Francisco’s mayor announced plans to introduce legislation this fall that will impose a fee on retailers selling sugary drinks, including soda. And President Obama was quoted as saying that soda taxes need to “be explored” as a way to reduce childhood obesity.
Not surprisingly, these proposed taxes are facing fierce opposition. This past Sunday’s Washington Post contains an opinion piece dispelling the 5 “myths” about soda taxes. Coca Cola’s CEO has weighed in on the issue calling a soda tax “socialist.” And anyone who reads a Sunday newspaper has surely seen the full-page ads run by Americans Against Food Taxes (aka, the beverage industry).
Opponents say that recent tax proposals aren’t large enough to impact obesity. That might be true, but they are missing the point. Drinking fewer sugary drinks has no downside (except possibly to the reduced profits of the beverage industry). These drinks push out healthier options like low-fat milk or water, and flood the body with excess calories that are rarely burned off and increase blood sugar levels. Teens consume the most soda and other sugary drinks, and are also historically price sensitive. Limiting their consumption of sugary drinks would cut their risk for obesity, diabetes, and cardiovascular disease, all costly health problems. And with states cutting essential programs and services, they should be looking to increase revenue wherever possible. Soda taxes seem like a win-win situation.
Alyson Hazen Kristensen, MPH
Senior Fellow & Program Officer
Partnership for Prevention
Such taxes are also being discussed by policymakers. San Francisco’s mayor announced plans to introduce legislation this fall that will impose a fee on retailers selling sugary drinks, including soda. And President Obama was quoted as saying that soda taxes need to “be explored” as a way to reduce childhood obesity.
Not surprisingly, these proposed taxes are facing fierce opposition. This past Sunday’s Washington Post contains an opinion piece dispelling the 5 “myths” about soda taxes. Coca Cola’s CEO has weighed in on the issue calling a soda tax “socialist.” And anyone who reads a Sunday newspaper has surely seen the full-page ads run by Americans Against Food Taxes (aka, the beverage industry).
Opponents say that recent tax proposals aren’t large enough to impact obesity. That might be true, but they are missing the point. Drinking fewer sugary drinks has no downside (except possibly to the reduced profits of the beverage industry). These drinks push out healthier options like low-fat milk or water, and flood the body with excess calories that are rarely burned off and increase blood sugar levels. Teens consume the most soda and other sugary drinks, and are also historically price sensitive. Limiting their consumption of sugary drinks would cut their risk for obesity, diabetes, and cardiovascular disease, all costly health problems. And with states cutting essential programs and services, they should be looking to increase revenue wherever possible. Soda taxes seem like a win-win situation.
Alyson Hazen Kristensen, MPH
Senior Fellow & Program Officer
Partnership for Prevention
SF Pavement to Parks Program, Feds' Delay in Telling Schools about Food Recalls Named "Best, Worst Prevention Ideas of the Week"
A San Francisco program that turns unused roadway areas into parks was named Partnership for Prevention's "Best Prevention Idea of the Week," while federal officials’ delay in informing schools about potentially tainted food was named “Worst Prevention Idea of the Week.”
The Best/Worst Idea awards are a regular feature of Prevention Matters, the blog of Partnership for Prevention. Each week, Partnership for Prevention's staff will choose the designees based on nominations of items in the previous week's news submitted by members, staff and the public at large. To submit a nomination or for more information, contact Damon Thompson at dthompson@prevent.org.
BEST
SF PROGRAM TRANSFORMS PAVEMENT INTO PARKS
http://arieff.blogs.nytimes.com/2009/09/22/pavement-to-parks/?emc=eta1
San Francisco’s “Pavement to Parks” program creates green spaces where people can walk and be active by reclaiming excess roadway, through the use of simple and low-cost design interventions. A pro bono designer works on each park (there are 12 scheduled to be finished through 2010; three have just been completed) with the mandate of using materials the city already has to maximize greenery and “transform a sea of asphalt.”
WORST
U.S. DELAYED TELLING SCHOOLS ABOUT FOOD RECALLS
http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/32989396/ns/health-kids_and_parenting/?ocid=twitter/from/ET
The federal government failed to inform schools of recalls of suspected tainted food products, potentially putting millions of schoolchildren at risk of food poisoning over the last two years, a government investigation has concluded. The recalled foods included salmonella-tainted peanut products linked to the deaths of at least nine people, said the report, which was completed last month by the Government Accountability Office, the investigative arm of Congress.
The Best/Worst Idea awards are a regular feature of Prevention Matters, the blog of Partnership for Prevention. Each week, Partnership for Prevention's staff will choose the designees based on nominations of items in the previous week's news submitted by members, staff and the public at large. To submit a nomination or for more information, contact Damon Thompson at dthompson@prevent.org.
BEST
SF PROGRAM TRANSFORMS PAVEMENT INTO PARKS
http://arieff.blogs.nytimes.com/2009/09/22/pavement-to-parks/?emc=eta1
San Francisco’s “Pavement to Parks” program creates green spaces where people can walk and be active by reclaiming excess roadway, through the use of simple and low-cost design interventions. A pro bono designer works on each park (there are 12 scheduled to be finished through 2010; three have just been completed) with the mandate of using materials the city already has to maximize greenery and “transform a sea of asphalt.”WORST
U.S. DELAYED TELLING SCHOOLS ABOUT FOOD RECALLS
http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/32989396/ns/health-kids_and_parenting/?ocid=twitter/from/ET
The federal government failed to inform schools of recalls of suspected tainted food products, potentially putting millions of schoolchildren at risk of food poisoning over the last two years, a government investigation has concluded. The recalled foods included salmonella-tainted peanut products linked to the deaths of at least nine people, said the report, which was completed last month by the Government Accountability Office, the investigative arm of Congress. Friday, 25 September 2009
BMJ: Evidence Doesn't Support Widespread Prostate Screening
From the Schwitzer health news blog: This week's edition of the BMJ publishes a study, an analysis and an editorial all showing that there isn't enough evidence to support population-wide prostate screening with the PSA blood test. (Subscription required to access full text of all of these.)
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)